Arcadia Historical Society Mystery Dinner

On Sunday, November 12th, the Arcadia Historical Society celebrated its 65th birthday with a Mystery Dinner at Prince Erik Hall. Based on a real murder case that occurred at a gas station that once existed on Foothill Blvd., guests had to choose the murder from a cast of characters, helped along by clues placed at each table.  In the real case, it was rumored that Charles Forbes and Marge Jones buried their loot from a heist in the San Gabriel Mountains above Arcadia.  Though the ‘treasure’ has not yet been found, residents continue to hunt for it.  

The evening began with photos in front of a vintage truck and being fingerprinted by volunteers dressed in ’20s garb.  Guests then entered the reception hall and enjoyed Vodka Fresca martinis, wine and appetizers while waiting for the evening to begin.  And it began with a bang, with an actor being ‘shot’ before guests were led to the dining area to be ‘interrogated’ about the crime.

Guests at each table read clues to help determine which character took part in the crime, and in the end the ‘murderer’ was the sharp shooting ‘Annie Oakley,’ playing by Kim Brink, who committed the crime at the request of ‘Lady B Goode,’ portrayed by City Councilwoman April Verlato, who was the ex-wife of the vicious killer, Charles Forbes.  In the end, all characters were involved in some sort of illicit activities.

Arcadia Historian, Carol Libby researched the history of the event, with Sandi McQuilkin writing the script, and the cast of characters included local Arcadians.

Ruby Red, Bank Teller – Jan Shimmin

Phil R Up, Gas Station Owner – Lee Shimmin

Dr. Hobbs Knobbs – former Mayor Bob Harbicht

Macun A. Deal, Pawn Shop Owner – Burton Brink

Shady Sal, Speak Easy Manager – Lisa Walton

Rip Toff, Jeweler – City Clerk Gene Glasco

Deputy Fife, Police Officer – Mayor Pro-Tem Sho Tay

Tawney Chablis, Newspaper Editor – Galen Patterson

Lady B. Goode, Gangster Forbes’ Wife – City Councilwoman April Verlato

Annie Oakley, Gun Shop Owner – Kim Brink  


The dinner menu included a West Egg Caesar Salad, Carraway Stuffed Chicken Breast, Swanky Beef Tri Tip, Dolled Up Vegetables & Hotsy Totsy Roasted Potatoes, Attaboy Bread and Butter, and for dessert a Nifty Very Berry Strudel.

The night also honored the first recipient of the Carol Libby Youth Scholarship Award, given to an Arcadia High School student who not only showcased excellence in academics, but also an interest in the history of Arcadia.  Adrianna Togelang was on hand along with her family to accept.



  • Posted November 13, 2017 Connie Russell 5:55 pm

    Was a Lovely event!!! Great people!!

  • Posted November 14, 2017 Carol Libby 10:10 am

    A Delightful Event enjoyed by enthusiastic guests and performers.

Comments are closed.

Translate »